Back to chapters

CHAPTER 18:

BOOK AND MOVIE REVIEWS

This chapter explains how book reviews are helpful and describes some important book review indexes.
It also discusses sources for locating motion picture reviews. 



 

 

 

Book Reviews: A book review is a relatively brief description of the contents of a book along with an evaluation of the book's quality. A book review also may include some information about the author. Usually book reviews are published in periodicals, especially newspapers and scholarly journals. Some periodicals, for example The New York Review of Books, in fact contain nothing but book reviews. The major purpose of a book review is to tell potential readers what a book is about and whether it might be worth reading. These are the reasons reviews usually appear when a book is first published.

Book reviews not only are a good source of information about a book, they sometimes are the only source, especially if a book fails to be recognized as “literature” according to the definition offered in Chapter Seventeen. This usually means that the book will receive little or no critical or interpretive attention, unless, of course, the person who wrote the book goes on to become famous. 

Book reviews rarely summarize books. Instead they describe the book's main themes, the questions the author is attempting to answer, and the reviewer’s opinion of the ultimate value of the book. For this reason, reading a review is never an adequate substitute for reading the book, even though the review may give a good idea of the book's quality. 

Tens of thousands of book reviews are published every year, and popular and/or important books may be reviewed in several different periodicals. For these reasons, book review indexes are essential when you wish to locate reviews of a particular book.

To find reviews, you will usually need to know the book’s exact title, the author's name, and year of publication.  The Library’s online catalog is a good place to begin looking for this information. If the Library doesn’t own the book, the Internet database WorldCat almost certainly will contain a description, since it catalogs over 40,000,000 books. WorldCat is included in the Article Indexes and Online Databases link on the Library website. 

Two particularly important print guides to book reviews are the BOOK REVIEW INDEX, which lists reviews from over 400 magazines and scholarly journals; and the BOOK REVIEW DIGEST, which not only lists reviews, but also provides brief excerpts from many reviews.  A book review will include the name of the reviewer and the abbreviated title of the magazine or journal in which the review appears. To find the full title of an abbreviated journal check the beginning of the volume to find the list of abbreviated titles used in that publication.  There is now an Internet version of BOOK REVIEW DIGEST with the same title that contains reviews of over half a million books. It is accessible from the Library’s website through the Article Indexes and Databases link. 

Two important Internet sources of book reviews are Academic OneFile, BOOKS IN PRINT, and National Newspapers. Both can be accessed from the Library’s website through the Article Indexes and Databases path. To find reviews, type the phrase: book reviews and keywords connected by the Boolean operator and.  For example: book reviews and McCarthy and Horses. 

For reviews of scholarly books published before 1985, see the book review sections of ART INDEX, SOCIAL SCIENCE INDEX, GENERAL SCIENCE INDEX, HUMANITIES INDEX, BUSINESS PERIODICALS INDEX, BIOLOGICAL & AGRICULTURAL INDEX, and the APPLIED SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY INDEXAll are located in the Reference Index area.

A particularly comprehensive index for reviews of scholarly books is the COMBINED RETROSPECTIVE INDEX OF REVIEWS IN SCHOLARLY JOURNALS, 1886-1974 (15 vols.), which indexes over one million reviews contained in 459 social science journals ranging from history to anthropology to political science. For many older, scholarly books, this is the only useful index.  Book reviews in magazines can be located best using the printed volumes of READERS' GUIDE TO PERIODICAL LITERATURE, which also exists as an Internet index. 

Motion Picture Reviews: Found under Article Indexes and Online Databases, both Academic OneFile and National Newspapers are a good source of motion picture reviews as well. Type the phrase Motion Picture Reviews and key words or phrases from the title of the motion picture. The Internet itself abounds in sources for movie reviews. Simply select a search engine e.g., Google and type movie reviews. MRQE: Movie Review Query Engine: http://www.mrqe.com and The Internet Movie Database http://www.imdb.com are particularly comprehensive.


Click on link to go to the Assignments page and print Assignment EIGHTEEN

http://library.boisestate.edu/skills/locate/assignments.htm